Can you explain to a 5th grader?

“Have you heard of Raspberry Pi?” asked my friend, Rohit Chaudhri.

That conversation was the beginning of our year long journey teaching computer programming to bunch of 5th graders, on weekends.

If you are wondering what Raspberry Pi is, it is a low cost, credit-card sized computer – a favorite of Automation and Internet Of Things(IOTS) community.

Rohit had an ambitious goal to enable kids to build an automation project using Raspberry PI which required learning basics of electricity, electronics, computer and programming.

I had my reservations considering these topics are relatively complex and can be overwhelming for 5th graders. But I trusted his instincts and partnered to play a support role.

Rohit began his first session carrying a tiny flashlight. He flicked the switch couple of times asking: “what do you see?”. Kids replied with some amusement: “Light is On or Light is OFF”

“That is what you need to remember – light is ON or OFF. Computer and internet are built on the concept of ON and OFF. ON represents 1 and OFF represents 0 – referred as a bit. We will go over various topics in upcoming classes and you might feel they are complicated. But don’t let it overwhelm you – keep in mind the underlying concept is simple -Light is ON or OFF. “

Kids were listening attentively. They were connected and absorbing. Rohit’s messaging was effective.

It made me think. What enabled him to deliver a complex topic in such a simple way that even a 5th grader could understand in few minutes.

Use of flashlight was a great idea but I was intrigued – there is something more to it than the use of analogy. This experience and thought stayed with me.

During this time, I was working on a proposal. Proposal’s goal was to drive cost reduction in client’s massively complex and expensive business process. Our solution was leveraging innovative and leading-edge technologies.

I was confident of our solution and excited to present to my client. To my dismay my presentation turned out to be a nightmare. My client didn’t connect with what I was proposing. I was at the brink of losing a huge opportunity which I was working on for months.

I was wondering what went wrong.

A thought came to my mind – what if I had to present my proposal to 5th graders? What will make them connect? What will make them understand?

That led to series of questions.

Why Rohit was able to connect? It struck to me it was the simplicity of his message.

What made his message so simple? I realized it was the clarity.

But then how does one get the clarity? Answer is not that simple but definitely there has to be some level of critical thinking to seek clarity.

But then what is critical thinking?

How do you know you have done enough thinking?

How do you know you have enough clarity?

How do you know you have enough simplicity?

Many questions, no precise answer. But I decided to try something different.

Next day I gathered my team and told them we are going to reset ourselves. I want us to forget our solution and start with describing the problem in three (or fewer) phrases. There was silence and puzzlement at first. Then the discussion stared to flow. Arguments and counter-arguments went on for hours. Biggest surprise – we thought we knew it all – we didn’t. After few attempts, we boiled down the problem in three key phrases.

Problem:

We are dealing with an expensive business process because:

1. lack of standardization across disparate subprocesses

2. lack of measurements (metrics) which constrained systemic analysis and improvement

3. intensive human efforts throughout the process

Next step of casting the solution in three key phrases came out easier than I had thought as now we had better clarity on problem statement.

Solution:

We will drive significant savings by.

1. standardization across disparate subprocesses;

2. infusing measurements across the processes which will enable us to systemic analysis and improvement, leading to

3. higher level of automation throughout the process

On our comeback, in few simple phrases I conveyed the problem and the solution. Client was connected in first few minutes. Client was resonating to the message. The key was underlying

simplicity. This helped opening up the door to further explain details why we were in the best position to deliver the solution, eventually winning the opportunity.

Obviously, simplicity in communication is very powerful but it is not easy. There is no one size fits all solution, but I am sharing here a three-step framework that has worked for me and hope it help others.

Step -1 Mindset – Accept you never know enough.

This mindset is critical. Often, we believe we are thinking but in fact we are rearranging our biases. Besides biases there is a subtle influence of our ego that constraints us in accepting others thought. As in the example of my proposal I thought I knew problem well which prevented me from seeking further clarity.

Step -2 Seeking clarity – how?

Tactic I use – challenge myself to describe the subject in three or fewer phrases? This forces critical thinking which helps me attains clarity on the subject.

Step -3 Simple but not simpler – when is enough?

Bounce your idea to others – someone who is not part of your team. This helps you get you an outside-in perspective and audience’s perspective. If your message resonates in few minutes, you have enough simplicity to move forward. If not, calibrate and iterate.

Hope this helps. I would love to hear your side of the story from your experiences.

Comments

33 responses to “Can you explain to a 5th grader?”

  1. Naimish Avatar
    Naimish

    deep dive in to simplicity, and very well crafted article.

    Want to see many more…

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar

      Naimish, thank you very much

  2. Ninita Avatar
    Ninita

    Awesome! Loved reading!

  3. Neelesh Avatar
    Neelesh

    Any fool can make something complex, it takes a genius to make somethIng siMpler.

    Great write up. Keep them coming.

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar

      🙂 well said ..Neelesh ..thanks

  4. Deepika Gupta Avatar
    Deepika Gupta

    Simple is elegant.
    I believe that a piece of writing takes an idea from one mind to another. Keep writing and spreading yours.

    ENJOYED READING ON MY PARTICULARLY BAD COMMUTE TODAY (BUS RUNNING LATE, TRAFFIC BAD).

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar

      Deepika, thank you ..

      1. Deepika Gupta Avatar
        Deepika Gupta

        Sorry for caps lock. When writing comments it does not show the formatting like that and cant be changed later, it seems.

  5. Bijal Shah Avatar
    Bijal Shah

    Nice Analogy to drive a point home.
    Good one, Sanjay!!!

    Let the end user see wiifm (What’s in it for me), and everyone looks for a solution.

    Keep it going, man…

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar

      i like wiifm ..what’s in it for me.. thanks Bijal

  6. Sanjay Avatar
    Sanjay

    Well said Sanjay

  7. Rupesh Dhruv Avatar
    Rupesh Dhruv

    Yes..you r right…. simplicity.. with clarity…. .AND it’s really work….

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar
  8. Kalpendu Avatar
    Kalpendu

    Bingo.. sanjay!! Simple is always clear (true), divine and beautiful
    SATYAm…SHIVAm…sundaram

  9. Mina Avatar
    Mina

    Great article

  10. Rajesh Mahedu Avatar
    Rajesh Mahedu

    Well explained Sanjay..even it goes in poetry like this..સાવરી સુરતકો સંવરનેકી જરૂરત ક્યા હૈ, સાદગી હી તો કયામત કી અદા હોતી હૈ. in short.. simple is beautiful.

  11. Ashesh Patel Avatar
    Ashesh Patel

    Deep THOUGHTFULLY Wrote

  12. hARISH Avatar
    hARISH

    nICe READ, sANJAY! sIMPLICITY IS HARD TO ACHIEVE AND KEY TO MAKE THINGS FIT BEST. kEEP ON WRITING!!

  13. DP Avatar
    DP

    AMAZING WRITE UP. IT IS INFACT COMPLEX TO BE SIMPLE 🙂

  14. Krishna Avatar
    Krishna

    Putting this simple thing into simple words is not really simple but you well crafted this sanjay. Good lesson for my next proposal😊thanks

  15. Mintoo dave Avatar
    Mintoo dave

    The influence of the Ego is the constraint. simplicity comes from innocence, not from the intellect only. getting rid of unnecessary is simplicity. thank you for the thought-provoking writeup. keep it up.

  16. Varshesh Badheka Avatar
    Varshesh Badheka

    Excellent! Very simply shown the method of a very challenging skill of clear and effective communication ! I knew you are an excellent orator, learnt you are excellent with pen too!

  17. Nafis Patel Avatar
    Nafis Patel

    I WILL BE HONEST FIRST TIME FINISHED MIDDLESEAT POST. WILL NEED TO MAKE IT HABIT. 🙂 WELL WRITTEN

    1. Nafis Patel Avatar
      Nafis Patel

      and can’t figure out why is it taking all caps 🙂

  18. Clifford Eslick Avatar
    Clifford Eslick

    I recently got to experience the opportunity to substitute teach 5th, 6th, 7th and 8th graders in Math and Social Studies, in rural Missouri. I have a great respect for our teachers. They work so hard and for little pay.
    Here are some thoughts about your 3 step framework, from recently working with 5th through 8th graders.
    Step 1 – Attitude – Think of yourself as a teacher, who always learns more than the students, each time you teach. “When you are green you grow and when you are ripe you rot”. I personally have to work hard on keeping an open mind with no pre-defined expectations. I have to keep my past experiences at bay. I found myself asking so many questions from the students. They basically made me do the data gathering, just so I could teach them effectively.
    Step 2 – Clarity comes from feedback – Don’t be afraid to get scared. It really scared the heck out of me, on my first day of being a substitute teacher. I found myself learning more than the students. Can I even communicate to a fifth grader? The key was in connecting all the dots which was everyone in the room or on your team. Your payday is when the student says “I get it” and now you know the minimum required to achieve clarity.
    Step 3 – Simplicity – I seek to find what is common through what I see in my observations. For example, what I found from teaching 2nd graders through 8th grade in math, was Algebra. All of the grades have word problems. I found that writing down what you know, and then writing down the problem statement together with the whole class engaged, brought about much better results.

    1. Sanjay Patel Avatar

      Cliff,

      Thank you for sharing your valuable experience. Love your when you green you grow mindset.

      Thank you very much. Sanjay

  19. Maulik RAVAL Avatar
    Maulik RAVAL

    Amazing article ! જીવન ના અનુભવ થી જોડાયેલું વર્ણન આ લેખ ને વધારે ધારદાર બનાવે છે.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *